Yes siree Bob, this country’s economic future is in the very best of hands.
With the release of some hard data, the effects of the first wave of President Obama’s stimulus program are now observable. Businesses receiving federal contracts participating in the program reported creating or saving more than 30,383 jobs in the first months of the program, based on less than $16 billion in federal contracts.
ProPublica has done some basic math on the program so far, and calculated scenarios that shed light on the value proposition as outlined by the Obama administration. Following is the ProPublica analysis by Christopher Flavelle:
On Thursday, the government released a flood of data about the stimulus, showing how 9,000 federal contractors spent their stimulus dollars — including the value of the contract, each project’s status, and how much each of the contractor’s five highest-paid officers were paid.
But when it came to presenting that data, Recovery.gov, the government’s official site for stimulus information, highlighted one number in particular, posting it on the site’s main page in large font: “JOBS CREATED/SAVED AS REPORTED BY FEDERAL CONTRACT RECIPIENTS: 30,383.” To make extra certain of getting viewers’ attention, the number itself appears in bright green.
As the economy continues to shed jobs , it’s easy to see why the administration is keen to highlight the number of jobs created by the stimulus. When the numbers were released, Jared Bernstein, the administration’s chief economist, said the job count “exceeds our projections,” adding that it supported the conclusion “that the Recovery Act did indeed create or save about 1 million jobs in its first seven months.”
But do the 30,000 jobs represent a good return? And since the federal contracts for which data was reported this week represent just a sliver of the overall stimulus package, what do they really say about the impact of the stimulus as a whole?
Let’s start with the 30,000 jobs themselves. The federal contracts in question represented $16 billion in stimulus spending. Assuming the number of created or saved jobs reported by each contract recipient was accurate—which, as we’ve reported before, is still an open question—that breaks down to $533,000 for each job. That’s more than five times the projection of the president’s own Council of Economic Advisers , which estimated in May that every $92,136 in government spending would create one job for one year.
That’s right, on your behalf, the Obama administration has “saved or created” a little over 30,000 jobs, spending over a half million dollars of borrowed taxpayer money to “save or create” each job. Oh, by the way, since Obama took office, the U.S. economy has lost 3.6 million jobs. What’s wrong with this picture?
But wait, there’s more Obama not good news! In just nine months, Obama and the Democrats have managed to triple the Bush era record deficit set last year. You go Obama, borrow that money, spend, spend, spend!
The Obama administration has released new deficit numbers, and they are not pretty.
The deficit for Fiscal Year 2009, which ended Sept. 30, came in at a record $1.42 trillion, more than triple the record set just last year.
In addition, future deficits are currently projected to total $9.1 trillion in the coming decade.
Do Direct Stimulus Jobs Really Cost $533,000 a Piece?!
First Hard Data on Stimulus Released
Firms report 30,000 new stimulus jobs
Stimulus jobs paying $500,000 — good work if you can get it
30,000 Stimulus Jobs, Many in D.C. Area, Reported
Federal contracts show 30,000 stimulus jobs
Federal Government says Preliminary Numbers Show 30,000 Jobs Created
On stimulus jobs reporting, a big ‘Oops’
2009 federal deficit surges to $1.42 trillion
U.S. Budget Gap Hits Record $1.4 Trillion
Treasury reports record deficit
U.S. FY 2009 budget deficit a record $1.417 trln
US budget deficit hits record 1.4 trillion dlrs: govt
Record-High Deficit May Dash Big Plans
Deficit Hits $1.4 Trillion, Complicating Stimulus Plans
US National Debt Clock
Read The Writing On The Wall
/have you had enough hope and change yet?
Filed under: Blog Entry Tagged: | American Recovery And Reinvestment Act Of 2009, Barack Obama, Budget Deficits, Chief Economist, Christopher Flavelle, Created Or Saved, Democrats, Economy, Fiscal Year 2009, George W. Bush, Jared Bernstein, National Debt, Obama Administration, ProPublica, Recovery.gov, Stimulus